By Timothy Ruppert
Pittsburgh Playwrights Theatre Company specializes in bringing exceptional new work to life, and its current production of Monteze Freeland’s Halloween-themed comedy Fishy Woo Woo Part 2 embodies that commitment, delivering an evening of winning silliness, festive disguises, and a multi-tiered lesson in the value of honesty.
While the play amplifies stories introduced in a piece that premiered two years ago, you don’t need to have seen the 2024 show to appreciate this continuation. Freeland deftly provides the platform information both familiar and new viewers need to enjoy this laugh-out-loud sequel. Credit also goes to the cast, led by Ethan Davis Butler as Shawn and Mils “MJ” James as Cordero, for revivifying the Fishy Woo Woos with delightful facility. Indeed, the smoothness with which this new chapter in the lives of the Fishy Woo Woos unfolds reminds me of BBC shows that televise their individual series over years without missing a step.
Recapping the plot would risk spoiling the fun of seeing how a Halloween party in Wilmington, Delaware, sparks revelations, discoveries, and confrontations, all unveiling the interwovenness of the characters’ lives and fates. Suffice it to say that Freeland writes with a keen sense of design, not simply by observing traditional Aristotelian unities of time, place, and action, but by placing the right detail at the right moment, rendering the outrageous so believable that we have cause to think as well as to chuckle.
Fishy Woo Woo Part 2 benefits from a wonderful cast, each of whom embraces the nonsense with authentic spirit. Butler’s astonishment as Shawn comes as little surprise, given that his talents merit entertainer-of-the-year acclaim (for example, his recent performance at the Pittsburgh New Works Festival was a tour de force of Broadway-level quality). No fainter praise belongs to James, whose portrayal of Cordero resonates with humanity from the first joke to the closing song. David Minniefield brings warmth and authority to the elder figure, Darnell, and demonstrates first-rate comedic timing. His claim that “I’m so straight, I once dissatisfied two women at the same time” is my vote for the second-most hilarious line in the play, outshone only by Cordero’s final recommendation of a name for the daughter the irrepressible Char (Cheryl Bates-White) carries. Emmanuel Elliot Key gives the put-upon Kaden, Darnell’s son, the self-assurance naïveté often engenders. Manny Walker adds to the absurdity as a menacing presence whose plan to expose secrets and deceptions leaves him a fish out of water amid this group of nutters.
Lovell McFadden ably directs this joyful show, with highlights including Willa Catherine Cotton’s brilliant costuming (particularly Bates-White’s jade-green Statue of Liberty gown) and DeVoughn “DeVo” Spratt and Teri(ana) Turner’s inspired sound work. Also look for what Tony Ferrieri (scenic design), Cheryl El-Walker (special effects, hair, and make-up), Marcus Southers (technical director), and Madeleine Steineck (lighting design) achieve. Reneé Sorrell stage manages with help from Faith Stephens. And, if you’re lucky, you may meet Producing Artistic Director Mark Clayton Southers’s dog when Southers introduces the performance.
With even more luck, Freeland will soon address his keyboard to Fishy Woo Woo Part 3. For now, though, make sure to see Fishy Woo Woo Part 2 before November arrives.
—TR
Pittsburgh Playwrights Theatre Company presents “Fishy Woo Woo Part 2” through November 1, 2026, at the Carter Woodson Redwood Theater, in the Madison Arts and Entertainment Center, 3401 Milwaukee Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15219. For more information, please visit here.

















