by Claire DeMarco
If you’re not familiar with “The Lonesome West” by Martin McDonagh, you might think that the play refers to the vast American West. But the play actually takes place in the western part of Ireland.
And it’s here that we meet Valene (Joseph McGranaghan) and Coleman (Jack Lafferty) – two brothers who just buried their father. Father Welsh (Corey Rieger), the local priest, also visits the brothers at their home after the funeral.
Valene and Coleman don’t like each other. In fact, they never have and once it is apparent that Valene now owns their father’s home and everything in it, tensions rise above the boiling point. Add to this toxic environment that both the brothers and Father Welsh like to drink.
Father Welsh is tortured and his melancholy reaches lower depths as he talks about the crimes and general mayhem that he knows were committed and ponders on how to rectify the town’s malaise. Although he is visiting the brothers to try to rehabilitate their relationship, he dwells on other confessions and situations that depress him even more than usual, imbibing alcohol the more despondent he becomes.
The brothers’ wrath escalates as they continue their vocal and physical attacks towards one another. Their pettiness even extends to mundane things like not sharing a bag of crisps (potato chips).
Joseph McGranaghan and Jack Lafferty – Photo by Rocky Raco
Entering the hostile environment, Girleen (Lexi Casey) sells poteen (Irish distilled spirits) to Valene. She holds her own against the brothers, dishing out verbal counter punches but avoids getting emotionally wrapped up in their anger. Girleen has a rapport with Father Welsh.
Now that we’ve discussed the absolute hatred of these two brothers, the drinking and insecurity of the priest (and the crimes he is aware of that prey on his mind), how can there possibly be any comic relief or laughter in this dire situation? But this comedy is deliciously outrageous with much of the humor coming from the brothers’ continual witty retorts and jabs at one another.
This ensemble works well together and should also be commended for their superb Irish dialects.
Lafferty excels as the bitter, constantly angry brother. He is sarcastic, his facial expressions menacing and his physical attacks threatening.
As more religious and the younger brother, McGranaghan’s obsession with his new possessions is both spiteful and funny as he never hesitates to remind Coleman who is in charge.
McGranaghan and Lafferty both work together well in the many acerbic and physical exchanges between them with timing critically important.
Rieger’s helplessness is palpable and he is overwhelmed and lacks confidence as the local priest, mostly with his inability to stop the brothers fighting. He is able to turn Father Welsh’s ineffectiveness into a strong statement that hopefully changes the brothers’ attitude towards one another.
Casey as Girleen is both tough and tender. She has a soft spot and affection for Father Welsh and handles the two brothers effectively.
“The Lonesome West” was written by Martin McDonagh.
Director Andrew Paul does a nice job of balancing the comedy with the violent aspects in this production.
Steve Tolin’s special effects are outstanding, especially the pivotal, inanimate orange stove that becomes a hilarious prop.
The physical fight scenes handled by Fight Director/Violence Coordinator Michael R. Petyak are tight and controlled.
Excellent job by Dialect Coach Brandi Welle. The accents were thoroughly convincing and flawless.
-CED
“The Lonesome West” is a production of Kinetic Theatre Company. Performances run from November 19th to December 20th at Carnegie Stage, 25 W. Main Street, Carnegie, PA 15106
For more information, click here.

















